In Chetan Sabharwal vs ACIT (2026 INSC 1163, decided 28.10.2026), the Supreme Court upheld the Section 148 notices reopening AY 2008-09 and AY 2009-10. The notices rested on a post-assessment DGIT (Investigation) report finding that the shares were overvalued, which the Court treated as tangible material with a live link to escapement of income.
The Court also held there was no change of opinion: one brother’s returns were processed only by a Section 143(1) intimation, and the other’s Section 143(3) assessment formed no opinion on the overvaluation or the Section 54F claim.
