ITAT Delhi held that Donaldson’s Indian subsidiary, DIFS, is neither a fixed place PE nor a dependent agent PE under Article 5 of the India-US DTAA. The AO relied only on group-level Form 10-K disclosures and website information, without showing that the premises were at Donaldson’s disposal.
DIFS was found to be economically independent, buying on a principal-to-principal basis with no authority to conclude contracts, so the ₹2.41 crore profit attribution was deleted.
