• Celebrate Festive season with Up to 50% OFF on VIDUR! 🪔 Explore Now

    SC Upholds Reopening Based on Investigation Report

    Written byVIDUR
    Published
    Sealed confidential file, representing an investigation report

    In Chetan Sabharwal vs ACIT (2026 INSC 1163, decided 28.10.2026), the Supreme Court upheld the Section 148 notices reopening AY 2008-09 and AY 2009-10. The notices rested on a post-assessment DGIT (Investigation) report finding that the shares were overvalued, which the Court treated as tangible material with a live link to escapement of income.

    The Court also held there was no change of opinion: one brother’s returns were processed only by a Section 143(1) intimation, and the other’s Section 143(3) assessment formed no opinion on the overvaluation or the Section 54F claim.